EQ2 Forum Archive @ EQ2Wire

 

Go Back   EQ2 Forum Archive @ EQ2Wire > EverQuest II > Chaos Descending Beta > Tradeskill Discussion
Members List Search Mark Forums Read

Notices

Reply
 
Thread Tools
Old 10-09-2018, 03:56 AM   #1
Caith

Developer
Caith's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jan 1970
Posts: 0
Default

Please provide all Weaponsmith related feedback here. Please remember to be specific, including recipe name and level.
Caith is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 10-11-2018, 11:55 PM   #2
Niami DenMother

Well-Known Member
Niami DenMother's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jan 1970
Posts: 0
Default

I *really* need someone else looking at the stats on these, as I just can't mentally focus on it right now. So please don't assume that because I've commented in this thread, I've checked these recipes out properly, k? BigGrin

That having been said

The 4 "student's satchel of ___" and the 4 "academic's satchel of ____" are crafted on the forge, but are asking for celestial filament instead of celestial coal.
Niami DenMother is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 10-14-2018, 05:25 AM   #3
Niami DenMother

Well-Known Member
Niami DenMother's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jan 1970
Posts: 0
Default

Using purified golden fleck on Academic's Katar of Evasion, Academic's Katar of Fortitude and Academic's Satchel of Endurance showed no "refined" label showing up on the recipe window before I started the combine, nor did it result in refined stats or the refined label on the weapons.

I didn't do further refined testing on my WS, as I'm going to go out on a limb and say something isn't working right with refines and the weapon recipes. BigGrin
Niami DenMother is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 10-16-2018, 03:06 AM   #4
Fellon63

New Member
Fellon63's Avatar
 
Posts: n/a
Default

Just wondering if the the following weaponsmith recipes have been corrected for Chaos Descending-

Level 103 Rubicite Greatsword of Energy crafts Hearthwoos Staff of Energy

Level 106 Rubicite Greataxe of Spirit crafts Heatwood Staff of Spirit

Level 109 Rubicite Greatsword of Rage crafts Heartwood Staff of Rage
  Reply With Quote
Old 10-17-2018, 11:31 PM   #5
Anadorr

New Member
Anadorr's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jan 1970
Posts: 0
Default

Advanced Weaponsmith Studies 4 - Academic's Axe of Rage - Both crafting icon and paperdoll preview show as longsword
Academic's Satchel of Energy - Icon is a hammer

Advanced Weaponsmith Studies 3 - Academic's Katar of Evasion - Icon appears to be a Hammer

Advanced Weaponsmith Studies 5 - Academic's Katar of Ruin - Icon is of a staff

Advanced Weaponsmith Studies 7 - Academic's Lance of Frenzy - Icon is a sword

Advanced Weaponsmith Studies 8 - Academic's Lance of Rage - Icon is a sword

Advanced Weaponsmith Studies 6 - Academic's Satchel of Ruin - Icon is a dagger
Anadorr is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 10-25-2018, 12:49 AM   #6
Whilhelmina

Well-Known Member
Whilhelmina's Avatar
 
Posts: n/a
Default

Bug :
icons:
handcrafted
There's a massive problem with icons on the handcrafted recipes. Worse being the student's dagger or force which uses a kryss icon WITH RARE PARTICLES.
Axes are using lance or gladius icons
Blades are using axe icons
Daggers are more like swords
Katars are 2 mauls and a glove?
There's a sword for a lance
Maces are using a bo and a censer
Tower of evasion is a hilt.
mastercrafted
Academic's Axe of rage uses a dagger/shortsword icon
Academic's Blade of Energy uses an axe icon
Academic's Dagger of Endurance and Energy aren't really dagger like but it can pass
Academic's Katars are using mauls and bo icons
Academic's Lances look more like swords than lances
Academic's Satchel of Energy looks like a mace


damage/name:
The katar is doing crush damage instead of pierce I guess. I think you missnamed them tbh. They don't look like katars either. At all.

price:
handcrafted
common stuff sells for 58g 33s 40c (10g margin)
The 3 student's blades sell for 1p 16g 66s 80c (20g margin)
Student's lance of force and frenzy sell for 1p 40g --> should be 1p 16g 66s 80c for consistency
Student's lance of rage sells for 1p 28g 33s 40c --> should be 1p 16g 66s 80c for consistency

mastercrafted
1H/range/shield sells for 1p 45g 83s 50c (24g margin)
2H sells for 2p 91g 67s (48g margin)
Academic's Blade's of Frenzy sells for 1 copper instead of 2p 91g 67s
Academic's Dagger of Energy sells for 1 copper instead of 1p 45g 83s 50c
Academic's Katar of Ruin sells for 1 copper instead of 1p 45g 83s 50c
Academic's Lance of Force sells for 1 copper instead of 2p 91g 67s
Academic's Mace of Endurance sells for 1 copper instead of 1p 45g 83s 50c
Academic's Mace of Frenzy sells for 1 copper instead of 1p 45g 83s 50c
Academic's Satchel of Ruin sells for 1 copper instead of 1p 45g 83s 50c


Fuel:
Common
Components are 10/2/2/2 +20 fuel (yield is 50 for consumables) doubled for 2 handed
crafting cost is 48g 61s 20c for 1H, 97g 22s 40c for 2H
Student's lances use 40 celestial sandpaper instead of 40 celestial coal
Student's maces use 20 celestial sandpaper instead of 20 celestial coal
Student's satchels use 20 celestial filament instead of 20 celestial coal
mastercrafted
Components are 1/10/10/10 +50 fuel for consumables (yield is 20-200)
1H use 2/10/10/10/50 doubled for 2H
crafting cost is 1p 21g 53s for 1H, 2p 43g 06s for 2H
Academic's lances use 100 celestial sandpaper instead of 100 celestial coal
Academic's maces use 50 celestial sandpaper instead of 50 celestial coal
Academic's satchels use 50 celestial filament instead of 50 celestial coal

Inconsistency
The effect on weapons between handcrafted and mastercrafted is nearly never the same (you'll have anguish turn into decisive strike and so on). No big deal, just making a note of it.

Stats
The golden throwing weapons are all off
The golden throwing axe is +651 slashing instead of +901 slashing
The Golden throwing hammer is +901 crushing instead of +1026 crushing
The Golden throwing dagger is +475 piercing instead of +651 piercing
The Golden Shuriken is only +425 slashing (there's no arrow with the same stats so can't say what it should be)
(Silvered ones are +641, +888, +468 and +419)
All other stats are fine and consistent.


Spreadsheet with all datas so far can be downloaded as a .xls file here : http://eq2artisans.faerylands.eu/uploads/images/CA-craft.xls
It's too late for purified now, I'll check tomorrow
  Reply With Quote
Old 10-25-2018, 04:19 PM   #7
Whilhelmina

Well-Known Member
Whilhelmina's Avatar
 
Posts: n/a
Default

How did I miss that one yesterday, that's a good question

Primary component miss-match
Academic's Lances are using Arborian Wedge as a primary component instead of Golden Fleck
Academic's Maces are using Arborian Wedge as a primary component instead of Golden Fleck

Student's Lances are using Dewpalm lumber as a primary component instead of Silvered Fleck
Student's Maces are using Dewpalm lumber as a primary component instead of Silvered Fleck


Made everything purified, everything works fine. The stats that don't change are health, power, resolve, crit bonus overcap, mitigation increase, block (and ammo/effects on weapons obviously).

Either prices were fixed in the patch or refined items work, but everything shows at the right price on the broker from today's batch.
  Reply With Quote
Old 10-27-2018, 04:09 AM   #8
Pheidra

New Member
Pheidra's Avatar
 
Posts: n/a
Default

Student's Katar of Fortitude looks like gloves rather than a weapon
Student's Axe of Rage looks like a sword
  Reply With Quote
Old 10-29-2018, 07:27 AM   #9
Sigrdrifa

Well-Known Member
Sigrdrifa's Avatar
 
Posts: n/a
Default

I have run out of brains from the lateness of the hour, so I will look over the student weapons tomorrow.

(1) Odd Materials
Academic's Maces and Lances require:
  • 2 Arborian Wedge
  • 10 strangler root
  • 10 wandervine fruit
  • 10 dewpalm lumber
  • 50 Celestial Sandpaper

Student's Maces and Lances require:
  • 10 dewpalm lumber
  • 2 nimbic hide
  • 2 reef cluster
  • 2 silvered fleck
  • 20 Celestial Sandpaper

All these weapons are crafted at a forge, even though they're using sandpaper as fuel. I woyld expect them to use coal if they're crafted on the forge.

The Academic's maces and lances components are just weird... squishy fruit and thread? Really? I would expect:
  • 2 Golden Fleck
  • 10 nimbic hide
  • 10 reef cluster
  • 10 silvered fleck
  • 50 Celestial Coal

(2) Icon / Graphic /Weapon Type Mismatches
Academic's Axe of Force
Icon: double-edged axe
Graphic: one-handed broadsword with a purple particle effect
aITEM -260530486 -1395703059 0 0 0:[Academic's Axe of Force]/a
PROBLEM: Either the graphic should be an actual one-handed axe of some type, or else this should be named "Academic's Broadsword of Force" and have a sword icon.

Academic's Axe of Fortitude
Icon: parrying dagger
Graphic: one-handed broadsword with purple particle effect
aITEM -348992134 -1794859729 0 0 0:[Academic's Axe of Fortitude]/a
PROBLEM: Either the graphic should be an actual one-handed axe of some type, or else this should be named "Academic's Broadsword of Fortitude" and have a sword icon.

Academic's Axe of Rage
Icon: Dagger
Graphic: one-handed broadsword with purple particle effect
aITEM 867863404 2022179757 0 0 0:[Academic's Axe of Rage]/a
PROBLEM: Either the graphic should be an actual one-handed axe of some type, or else this should be named "Academic's Sword of Force" and have a sword icon (the icon could slide, it's close enough to a sword).

Academic's Blade of Energy
Icon: single-edged axe
Graphic: two-handed greatsword with purple particle effect
aITEM 1107079917 2080076287 0 0 0:[Academic's Blade of Energy]/a
PROBLEM: This is a two-handed slashing weapon. "Blade" is nonspecific, so that's okay, but the icon should be a greatsword/sword, not an axe.

Academic's Blade of Fortitude
Icon: sword
Graphic: two-handed greatsword with purple particle effect
aITEM -501354502 16637376 0 0 0:[Academic's Blade of Fortitude]/a
ALL OKAY

Academic's Blade of Rage
Icon: machete/sword
Graphic: two-handed greatsword with purple particle effect
aITEM -1193154804 -226280099 0 0 0:[Academic's Blade of Rage]/a
ALL OKAY

Academic's Katar of Evasion
Icon: hammer
Graphic: Thalumbra crushing fist
aITEM -941689363 -1794697058 0 0 0:[Academic's Katar of Evasion]/a
PROBLEM: A katar is a push-knife, not a crushing weapon. The icon should be some kind of crushing fist, and the name should be something other than katar... maybe "Academic's Fist of Evasion".

Academic's Katar of Fortitude
Icon: hammer
Graphic: Thalumbra crushing fist
aITEM 788381360 1187425680 0 0 0:[Academic's Katar of Fortitude]/a
PROBLEM: A katar is a push-knife, not a crushing weapon. The icon should be some kind of crushing fist, and the name should be something other than katar... maybe "Academic's Fist of Fortitude".

Academic's Katar of Ruin
Icon: staff
Graphic: Thalumbra crushing fist
aITEM 1095403331 149833092 0 0 0:[Academic's Katar of Ruin]/a
PROBLEM: A katar is a push-knife, not a crushing weapon or staff. The icon should be some kind of crushing fist, and the name should be something other than katar... maybe "Academic's Fist of Ruin".

Academic's Lance of Force
Icon: spear
Graphic: two-handed spear
aITEM 1507870932 -958397245 0 0 0:[Academic's Lance of Force]/a
ALL OKAY

Academic's Lance of Frenzy
Icon: one handed saber
Graphic: two-handed spear
aITEM -1911257233 -1152509106 0 0 0:[Academic's Lance of Frenzy]/a
PROBLEM: The icon should be some kind of spear, not a sword/saber. This is a two-handed piercing weapon.

Academic's Lance of Rage
Icon: machete/sword
Graphic: spear
aITEM 402055534 -403775556 0 0 0:[Academic's Lance of Rage]/a
PROBLEM: The icon should be some kind of spear, not a machete/sword. This is a two-handed piercing weapon.

3) Shields
Armorers used to make shields. Why is a weaponsmith making shields?
  • aITEM 1868102199 -1402923518 0 0 0:[Academic's Tower of Evasion]/a
  • aITEM -762145031 -492756210 0 0 0:[Academic's Tower of Ruin]/a
  Reply With Quote
Old 11-03-2018, 10:30 PM   #10
Whilhelmina

Well-Known Member
Whilhelmina's Avatar
 
Posts: n/a
Default

Icons
Student's dagger or force still has rare particles on its icon
Academic's Satchel of Energy icon still looks like a mace
Crossbow bolts are using arrow icons (all of them)

Primary component miss-match
Academic's Lances are using Arborian Wedge as a primary component instead of Golden Fleck
Academic's Maces are using Arborian Wedge as a primary component instead of Golden Fleck

Student's Lances are using Dewpalm lumber as a primary component instead of Silvered Fleck
Student's Maces are using Dewpalm lumber as a primary component instead of Silvered Fleck

Stats
The golden throwing weapons are still all off
The golden throwing axe is +686 slashing instead of +948 slashing
The Golden throwing hammer is +948 crushing instead of +1081 crushing
The Golden throwing dagger is +500 piercing instead of +686 piercing
The Golden Shuriken is only +441 slashing (there's no arrow with the same stats so can't say what it should be)
(Silvered ones are +676, +934, +493 and +441)
All other stats are fine and consistent.
  Reply With Quote
Reply

Thread Tools

Forum Jump


All times are GMT. The time now is 02:43 AM.

vBulletin skin by: CompleteGFX.com
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.7.5
Copyright ©2000 - 2019, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
All threads and posts originally from the EQ2 and Station forums operated by Sony Online Entertainment. Their use is by express written permission.