I think if Puzzle were ranting and raving about how we're invading his guild's privacy, then that would be undeniable hypocrisy. From what I can see, he asked politely if there was a way to opt out guilds.
Is there anyway to have a guild roster on a guild portal site now? At one point you could do that from the old eq2players site. How would you go about doing that now? I can't use rostermaster as its just the Guildportal site and not my own php site.
Without a webhost, I'm not sure how you would do it. There are a lot of folks working with the API, so I imagine someone will produce a Javascript Guild Roster that you can embed in any website soon enough.