This list is more in line as it is imo.
DPS
1.Shadowknight
2.Monk
3.Bruicer
4.Berserk
5.Paladin
6.Guardian
Survivability.
1.monk
2.Bruicer
3.Guardian
4.Paladin
5.Shadowknight
6.Berserk
Pally and shadowknight both have ups and downs when it comes to surviving. SK:s have the most health and better death save but the pally still wins of the two imo. Claim that it is the other way around since SK have a stone skin is abit meh to be honest since both SK and zerk have that. But they ONLY work on Physical damage wich makes it useless for most stuff since not to many aoe:s/DT are physical.
I dont agree one bit with tallons fantacy on how it should be. The fact still stand that you need to look at UT aswell of the tanks and count that into the balance curve.