So Last Post was Permafrost and Mistmoore and its roughly 150,000 Profile Screw ups according to EQ2players database, Lets do Kithkor / Butcherblock here just for fun 
EQ2 Players Kithicor Current: 139,149
EQ2 Players Butcherblock current after merge: 159,383
Last Years Standing with these servers: BB: 158,228 / Kith: 149,483
http://forums.station.sony.com/eq2/...topic_id=465030
Cause we are roughly seeing about 139,149 In Missing Profiles or just straight out glitched ... Is there duplications .. Well yes there is 
Example: Guild A.
Kithicor Guild: http://everquest2.com/Guild/2712106/
Now in Buthcerblock: http://everquest2.com/Guild/5844108/
Gee I wonder if EQ2players is broken ? But I am supposed to be desperate according to the OP 
I guess your not supposed to see the screw ups, you just have to believe in the numbers posted ~