Sorry missed that - I cut and pasted offensive & defensive (to keep them in the same order) then went back and modified - fixed in orignal post now.
The Clarion figures are about right - now with 8 pts in Idolic Axe its showing 7.1 to 8.7k.
I'm not as optimistic. That we may have similar taunts to other tanks is a major problem. We have less survivability, less "Oops" abilities, and no compelling raid or group buffs. That we had the best aggro abilities when used with the right amends target used to balance these - now we are just a 2nd rate guardian with a few heals.