Jonaroth wrote:its funny our old MT (zerker) tried tanking black queen 10 times in a row, became totally naked. I tried it once first try killed him with a paly tankin. anyone who says palys cant tank dont know his [expletive haxx0red by Raijinn]
Or it could just be that ure ppl learned how to do the encounter during those first 10 whipes or that your zerk sucks or any other reason imaginable...If u straightly look at numbers though a warrior is the better tank (given u have the same gear and race with same traits- they got more hp, more avoidance, miti buffs, and resists doesnt matter cause u max em some other way) but ofcourse player skill > all else.
Add that to the fact that non-tanking a pally is alot more useful then a warrior not tanking and the choice is pretty clear imho who should be raidtank.
Key thing though is player skill > all else ... roll with whats work for u