"Guardians tanking ability is equal to all other fighters." Nice try at a cop-out Was. You never did answer my question about how your tanking ability is "equal" to other fighters when you do in fact still have the most HP, the most mitigation, the most avoidance, and the most taunts of all the fighter classes in the game. I know you think you're taunts are useless (which is bullcrap) but are also trying to say that HP, mitigation, and avoidance don't do a thing for you either? Well if that's true then I would like to know what you think does really matter.
"Guardian DPS is about 1/2 the average fighter DPS." Yeah well like I said that might have something to do with the fact that you get more of everything else that really matters in tanking than any other fighter. You can't realistically expect them to make it so that you have the most defensive capabilities and equal DPS with the rest of the fighter classes at the same time. Honestly, how is that fair? This is just ridiculous. You think that you are the only fighter class in the game that got any nerfs in the revamp and you refuse to listen to the truth, that we all got nerfed in one way or another. Just listen...I'm not trying to say that you don't have any problems that need to be fixed. We all do. But you really need to understand something...the only reason that Berserkers are equal to Guardians at tanking right now is because of the fact that we have more DPS than you. A lot more. Because like I said you get more of everything else. So it IS balanced. You just seem to keep forgetting all about that. Or maybe you just don't care. The fact is I really don't think you're quite as bad off as you want people to believe. I think the real problem here is that you just don't like the idea of any other tank in the game being able to hold a candle to your own tanking ability. Many of you guys still seem to insist on being the top tank in the game and the #1 choice for MT in all raids and groups all the time, no questions asked. It's like you just can't stand the idea of maybe having to assist another tank sometimes. Well like I said you better just get yourself out of that mentality or you will never be happy with your class again. That was the whole point of the combat revamp that came with LU13. That is the whole reason why other types of tanks exist in the game besides Guardians. So that there is a choice of different tanking styles and not just one uber tank class that is truely better than all the others making it totally useless to play any of the other classes that are available to do the same job. Just remember that we are all having problems right now. And being selfish isn't going to help the situation. We need to work together. But no, you don't want to cooperate with any of the other tanking classes to try and get our problems fixed, you only want your own problems fixed while leaving the rest of us gimped just so you can be overpowered again.
Message Edited by infernus006 on 12-29-2005 04:47 PM