Punishment AA - No Heals in PvP?

[Morogoth Drakul]

<p>Has anyone noticed that in PvP and BG that the punishments endline AA that gives the heal proc for Inquistors... doesn't proc at all?</p><p>I found it really odd and started looking at my parses more closely. Sure enough when im in PvE punishment shows as heals which is great, its working in PvE. However, in PvP and BG its nowhere to be found under anything. The description if you click the "PvP" button does vary but its still not being proc'd anywhere.</p><p>PvE:</p><ul><li>Applies Punishment.</li><li>Heals targets in Area of Effect for xxx - xxx.</li></ul><p>PvP:</p><ul><li>Applies Punishment.</li><li>Applies a small heal to the inquisitor's allies.</li></ul><p>So is this a know issue and being worked on? or has no one ever noticed it?</p>

[LardLord]

<p>The heal was working for me, but it is attributed to the target, not the Inquisitor.</p>

[Morogoth Drakul]

<p><cite>Quabi@Antonia Bayle wrote:</cite></p><blockquote><p>The heal was working for me, but it is attributed to the target, not the Inquisitor.</p></blockquote><p>Im not seeing it on my targets or on my inq. I know it states "allies" though that should include the inq himself i dont even see it amongst my group members during a BG or PvP battle.</p><p>can you possibly post a pic of it working? like in a parser. i would like to see.</p>

[LardLord]

<p>(1286774923)[Sun Oct 10 22:28:43 2010] YOUR Repenting Strike critically hits Antonia_Bayle.Daimiian for 133 divine damage.(1286774923)[Sun Oct 10 22:28:43 2010] Antonia_Bayle.Daimiian's Punishment critically heals YOU for 805 hit points.(1286774923)[Sun Oct 10 22:28:43 2010] Antonia_Bayle.Daimiian's Punishment critically heals Antonia_Bayle.Porphyry for 163 hit points.(1286774923)[Sun Oct 10 22:28:43 2010] Antonia_Bayle.Daimiian's Punishment critically heals Butcherblock.Surrat for 167 hit points.(1286774923)[Sun Oct 10 22:28:43 2010] YOUR Vengeance critically hits Antonia_Bayle.Daimiian for 605 divine damage.(1286774923)[Sun Oct 10 22:28:43 2010] Antonia_Bayle.Daimiian's Punishment critically heals YOU for 626 hit points.(1286774923)[Sun Oct 10 22:28:43 2010] Antonia_Bayle.Daimiian is struck by vengeance.</p>

[Morogoth Drakul]

<p><cite>Quabi@Antonia Bayle wrote:</cite></p><blockquote><p>(1286774923)[Sun Oct 10 22:28:43 2010] YOUR Repenting Strike critically hits Antonia_Bayle.Daimiian for 133 divine damage.(1286774923)[Sun Oct 10 22:28:43 2010] Antonia_Bayle.Daimiian's Punishment critically heals YOU for 805 hit points.(1286774923)[Sun Oct 10 22:28:43 2010] Antonia_Bayle.Daimiian's Punishment critically heals Antonia_Bayle.Porphyry for 163 hit points.(1286774923)[Sun Oct 10 22:28:43 2010] Antonia_Bayle.Daimiian's Punishment critically heals Butcherblock.Surrat for 167 hit points.(1286774923)[Sun Oct 10 22:28:43 2010] YOUR Vengeance critically hits Antonia_Bayle.Daimiian for 605 divine damage.(1286774923)[Sun Oct 10 22:28:43 2010] Antonia_Bayle.Daimiian's Punishment critically heals YOU for 626 hit points.(1286774923)[Sun Oct 10 22:28:43 2010] Antonia_Bayle.Daimiian is struck by vengeance.</p></blockquote><p>this is truly odd then. i did a search in my log in the eq2 fold thinking that maybe the parser was possibly the problem. but no, punishment does not appear anywhere in the battleground log. however vengeance apears many many times.</p><p>(1292113139)[Sat Dec 11 18:18:59 2010] YOUR Vengeful Faith heals YOU for 240 hit points.(1292113139)[Sat Dec 11 18:18:59 2010] You feel the effects of a vengeful faith.<strong>(1292113139)[Sat Dec 11 18:18:59 2010] YOUR Vengeance hits Befallen.Yosi for 318 divine damage.(1292113139)[Sat Dec 11 18:18:59 2010] Befallen.Yosi is struck by vengeance.</strong>(1292113139)[Sat Dec 11 18:18:59 2010] You double over in pain as sorrow overwhelms you.(1292113139)[Sat Dec 11 18:18:59 2010] Befallen.Yosi's Insidious Whisper hits YOU for 43 disease damage.(1292113140)[Sat Dec 11 18:19:00 2010] Befallen.Yosi's Shadow Coil heals Befallen.Yosi for 46 hit points.(1292113140)[Sat Dec 11 18:19:00 2010] Befallen.Yosi's Shadow Coil hits YOU for 41 disease damage.(1292113140)[Sat Dec 11 18:19:00 2010] Befallen.Yosi's Grave Sacrament hits YOU for 163 disease damage.(1292113140)[Sat Dec 11 18:19:00 2010] Befallen.Yosi's Soulrend hits YOU for 72 piercing damage.(1292113140)[Sat Dec 11 18:19:00 2010] YOUR Vengeful Faith critically heals YOU for 319 hit points.(1292113140)[Sat Dec 11 18:19:00 2010] You feel the effects of a vengeful faith.<strong>(1292113140)[Sat Dec 11 18:19:00 2010] YOUR Vengeance hits Befallen.Yosi for 312 divine damage.(1292113140)[Sat Dec 11 18:19:00 2010] Befallen.Yosi is struck by vengeance.</strong>(1292113140)[Sat Dec 11 18:19:00 2010] You are immune to Stun effects.(1292113140)[Sat Dec 11 18:19:00 2010] You are dazed as part of your soul is knocked from you.(1292113141)[Sat Dec 11 18:19:01 2010] Befallen.Yosi's Mana Sieve hits YOU for 42 disease damage.(1292113141)[Sat Dec 11 18:19:01 2010] YOUR Strike of Flames critically hits Befallen.Yosi for 281 divine damage.</p><p>see. you would think somewhere in there punishment would be there. but its not. in fact its not in my entire battleground log.  In your logs... the more recent ones are they still showing as working? or did they stop showing up after a certain time period?</p>

[LardLord]

<p>I had to look in an old log, since I'm a Templar now.  It's possible something broke it over the past couple months, but I think you're probably just on full health when it's triggering, so it has nothing at all to heal.  It doesn't show up at all if there's nothing to heal...looks like your reactive was likely capping you off in the log you pasted above.</p>

[Morogoth Drakul]

<p><cite>Quabi@Antonia Bayle wrote:</cite></p><blockquote><p>I had to look in an old log, since I'm a Templar now.  It's possible something broke it over the past couple months, but I think you're probably just on full health when it's triggering, so it has nothing at all to heal.  It doesn't show up at all if there's nothing to heal...looks like your reactive was likely capping you off in the log you pasted above.</p></blockquote><p>that was in bg and like you said it is suppose to proc punisment on your allies. besides that fact i have 2 days of bg logs that show nothing in them. i doubt in 2 days i was capped every single time it went off if it was procing only on me and not my groupmates.</p><p>i just leveled up to 80 today so im goin to start a new log file and see what the BGs tell me.</p><p>edit: the logs show the same stuff. i will post them if anyone wants me to. the summary of it is though the lack of punishment procing heals to anyone and the number of times it had where it should of went off.</p>

[Morogoth Drakul]

<p><strong><span style="text-decoration: underline;">UPDATE:</span></strong></p><p>I submitted a support ticket in hopes that it would get more attention than the forums here. Here is original post and response.</p><p><hr /></p><p>The inquisitor punishment AA grants heals when and punishment ability is triggered. However, this effect is not being triggered in pvp. In the log files the "punishment" effect should be shown. However, in pvp combabt this effect is absent.attached:* pve logfile - eq2log_Salathiel.txt* pvp logfile - eq2log_Salathiel_120.txt* pictures - PvP and PvE versions of Vengeance IV ability for reference.</p><hr /><p>Greetings, Salathiel!This is GM Audleigh responding to your petition regarding your Punishment AA. I have taken a look at the AA, and it appears that it should cast a heal when any of your Punishment spells (Vengeance, etc.) triggers an effect. I did notice that the spell description changes depending on which sort of combat you are engaged in:PvP:Applies Punishment.-Applies a small heal to the inquisitor's alliesPvE:Applies Punishment.Heals targets in Area of Effect for (amount)I did attempt to test the ability with my fellow GM's, but I did not ever see the heal go off when we were PvPing. I have submitted a report to our QA Team for review, and appreciate your patience as they take the time to test it out. For updates to this, and other issues, please keep an eye on our Official Hotfix/Update notes, which can be found at the following website: <a href="http://forums.station.sony.com/eq2/forums/show.m?forum_id=330" target="_blank">http://forums.station.sony.com/eq2/....m?forum_id=330</a>.If you have any further concerns, please feel free to submit another petition, and we will be happy to assist you!Merry Frostfell,GM Audleigh EnoughEverQuest IISony Online Entertainment</p><p><hr /><hr /></p><p>so now they are aware of it and it appears to have been reported to the next team responsible for seeing why its not working.</p><p>also: thanks to the gm there that took time to test it to see it not working right. i usually have good CS experiences and this one is also <img src="/smilies/283a16da79f3aa23fe1025c96295f04f.gif" border="0" alt="SMILEY" /></p>

[BrainCandy]

<p>I was all excited to get that endline ability today.  Then I fought someone in PvP and noticed it never triggered for me either. Thanks for submitting a ticket. </p><p>-BC</p>