Side by Side comparison of scout pets [Archive]

Firecracker

11-28-2007, 05:00 AM

I have done comparison of the scouts combat arts damage and found that the level 73 Shadowblade is behind what it should be. My results were done with AA abilty that allows us to be are pet if any want to know. Also to note I have all masters subscibedDamage for Poison Spike, Shadowy Garrote, Unseen Blade, Throat Gash, Shadestrike and Acidity is in this orderShadowy Stalker: 99-165 + 39 every 3 secs. 231-338 resist 65 277-462 118-198 + 39 4 secs NA NAShadowy Assassin: 153-256 + 54 every 3 secs. 328-539 resist 79 430-717 184-307 + 54 4 secs 738-1230 NANightshade: 216-360 + 69 every 3 secs. 412-668 resist 92 606-1010 259-433 + 69 4 secs 1039-1739 233-386 every 4 secsShadowblade: 221-369 + 70 every 3 secs. 429-700 resist 93 621-1035 266-443 + 70 4 secs 1065-1775 238-397 every 4 secs My version of what is should be is 288-473 + 83 every 3 secs 511-812 resist 104 782-1331 343-578 + 84 4 secs 1365-2298 377-512 every 4 secsI hoping I am not wrong here but the scout dps is lower then it should be considering difference's in levels on the others scouts. The last abiltiy was guess based on the differences I seen in the other abilities so I did guess on the last one I had nothing to gage it by since scout before was only one who had this ability added in. I have read another thread saying how pet buffs are not working but these findings are all scout pets without pet buffs but I will have to say I had my Int buff on so the question is this buff also not working on Tier 8 pets?

Supp

11-28-2007, 12:13 PM

I keep seeing reports of superficial spell upgrades here in the forums. Until I'm 80 (except perhaps for the tank pet), I'm keeping my prior spell lineup, so here's hoping that they realign our spells by then. BTW, AA's do not appear to be affecting the T8 pets. When you ran your comparisons, it's possible this bug could have affected your numbers. Has anyone heard of conjuror superficial spell upgrades, or any other mages for that matter?

Sabutai

11-28-2007, 12:44 PM

<cite>Cinnimon wrote:</cite><blockquote>I have done comparison of the scouts combat arts damage and found that the level 73 Shadowblade is behind what it should be. My results were done with AA abilty that allows us to be are pet if any want to know. Also to note I have all masters subscibedDamage for Poison Spike, Shadowy Garrote, Unseen Blade, Throat Gash, Shadestrike and Acidity is in this orderShadowy Stalker: 99-165 + 39 every 3 secs. 231-338 resist 65 277-462 118-198 + 39 4 secs NA NAShadowy Assassin: 153-256 + 54 every 3 secs. 328-539 resist 79 430-717 184-307 + 54 4 secs 738-1230 NANightshade: 216-360 + 69 every 3 secs. 412-668 resist 92 606-1010 259-433 + 69 4 secs 1039-1739 233-386 every 4 secsShadowblade: 221-369 + 70 every 3 secs. 429-700 resist 93 621-1035 266-443 + 70 4 secs 1065-1775 238-397 every 4 secs My version of what is should be is 288-473 + 83 every 3 secs 511-812 resist 104 782-1331 343-578 + 84 4 secs 1365-2298 377-512 every 4 secsI hoping I am not wrong here but the scout dps is lower then it should be considering difference's in levels on the others scouts. The last abiltiy was guess based on the differences I seen in the other abilities so I did guess on the last one I had nothing to gage it by since scout before was only one who had this ability added in. I have read another thread saying how pet buffs are not working but these findings are all scout pets without pet buffs but I will have to say I had my Int buff on so the question is this buff also not working on Tier 8 pets?</blockquote>Ok come back and do this again when you're 80. Your numbers are completely out of whack from what they are at 80, and yes the pet buffs from the aa lines are not being applied to the t8 pets yet.

Sosum

11-28-2007, 01:24 PM

<cite>Sabutai wrote:</cite><blockquote><cite></cite>Ok come back and do this again when you're 80. Your numbers are completely out of whack from what they are at 80, and yes the pet buffs from the aa lines are not being applied to the t8 pets yet.</blockquote>I plan on further testing at 80 as well..I am 77 and scout spec'd and did some very encouraging parses compared to the other 80 necro using the mage pet. Ob visouly I won't post as they are meaningless without full lvl80 and all t8 spells scribed (t8 hostile spells adept3 and pet/grp buffs are t7 master)AA:Summonerstr 4-4-4-8agi 4-6-4-8-1wis 4-4-4-8

Xalmat

11-28-2007, 02:00 PM

You fail to mention two things. Without these, your data is invalid.1. Your current level.2. Your pet's ranks. There's a big difference between having an Adept III and a Master I pet.

Sosum

11-28-2007, 02:07 PM

<cite>Xalmat wrote:</cite><blockquote>You fail to mention two things. Without these, your data is invalid.1. Your current level.2. Your pet's ranks. There's a big difference between having an Adept III and a Master I pet.</blockquote>who?OP posted lvl73 (assuming) and I posted as lvl77

Xalmat

11-28-2007, 02:12 PM

My apologies, I was referring to the OP.

Virulence

11-28-2007, 04:04 PM

<cite>Sosumya@Unrest wrote:</cite><blockquote><cite>Sabutai wrote:</cite><blockquote><cite></cite>Ok come back and do this again when you're 80. Your numbers are completely out of whack from what they are at 80, and yes the pet buffs from the aa lines are not being applied to the t8 pets yet.</blockquote>I plan on further testing at 80 as well..I am 77 and scout spec'd and did some very encouraging parses compared to the other 80 necro using the mage pet. Ob visouly I won't post as they are meaningless without full lvl80 and all t8 spells scribed (t8 hostile spells adept3 and pet/grp buffs are t7 master)AA:Summonerstr 4-4-4-8agi 4-6-4-8-1wis 4-4-4-8</blockquote>Im interested in toying around with the T8 scout pet, please post any dps data you have for the scout vs. mage once you have 'apples and apples' comparison data.

KBern

11-28-2007, 04:17 PM

Yeah it would be funny if the scout pet turns out to be the main raid pet for T8.Would be nice to see some parses in the future the more people get geared up.